LocalCommentary.com
David Rodeback's Blog

Local Politics and Culture, National Politics,
Life Among the Mormons, and Other Stuff

Normal Version

Wednesday, June 7, 2006
Marriage Protection Amendment Dies on the Senate Floor

The Marriage Protection Amendment died today in a cloture vote. It will be back.


Forty-nine US Senators, mostly Republicans, voted yea. Forty-eight, mostly Democrats, voted nay. (Here's the roll call, and here's a brief CBN article.) Three did not vote. Here's why this one-vote margin, an apparent victory, is a defeat for the S. J. Res. 1, to propose the Marriage Protection Amendment for ratification by the states.

It is widely known that a Senate filibuster is stopped by a cloture vote, which requires a three-fifths majority, or 60 of 100 Senators, if all are voting. Less known is that a cloture vote is the normal means of closing debate and bringing an issue to a vote, even when there is no filibuster. Today's vote was on cloture -- specifically, a "Motion to Invoke Cloture on the Motion to Proceed to the Consideration of S. J. Res. 1" -- so it fell ten votes short of passage, even though more voted yea than nay. Although this vote is technically on bringing the resolution to a vote, not on the resolution itself, the resolution itself is essentially dead. Passage of the resolution itself would have required a two-thirds majority, so it's not as if the cloture defeat blocked something that would otherwise have happened.

House of Representatives leadership says it will bring the resolution to a vote there anyway. It's a election year, after all, and Republicans want Democrats on the record in a roll call vote. One house down, one to go.

No doubt a similar resolution will be introduced in the next session. If Congress is still under Republican leadership, it might get a little further than it did this time.


Normal Version